QM Scorecard Pack for Contact Centers
Four ready-to-use templates: inbound service, outbound sales, complaint handling and AI caller
Updated: 19 November 2026 · Template, free to use and adapt
These four scorecards give QM one shared, defensible basis for scoring calls. Each card has weighted categories, two to four checkpoints per category, and clearly marked auto-fail criteria. Adapt the weights and checkpoints to your processes, but keep the same card for every agent on a line: that is the only way the scores stay comparable.
How to score
Per checkpoint: 2 = met, 1 = partly met, 0 = not met, n/a = not applicable (excluded from the total).
Category score = points earned divided by points possible, times the category weight.
Overall score = sum of the category scores, giving 0 to 100 percent.
Auto-fail (K.o.): if an auto-fail criterion is breached, the call scores 0 percent regardless of points. Record the reason and evidence in the notes field.
Inbound Service
Card 1 of 4
For inbound service and support calls: information, orders, contract questions, technical support.
| Category | Checkpoints | Weight | Score |
| Call opening |
- Greeting with company and own name
- Friendly, ready-to-help start
|
10% | ___ / 4 |
| Needs discovery |
- Active listening, lets the caller finish
- Targeted follow-up questions
- Request captured correctly and in full
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Resolution competence |
- Technically correct and complete answer
- Resolved on first contact (FCR)
- On transfer: reason given and context handed over
|
30% | ___ / 6 |
| Call handling |
- Plain language, no unexplained jargon
- Friendliness and empathy throughout
- Call steered with confidence, no drift
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Call closing |
- Solution or next steps summarized
- Checks whether everything is resolved
- Friendly sign-off
|
15% | ___ / 6 |
| Data protection and verification (K.o.) |
- Identity or authorization checked before disclosure
- No data shared with unauthorized parties
|
5% | ___ / 4 |
Auto-fail: no verification before disclosure, or data shared with unauthorized parties = call scores 0 percent.
Outbound Sales
Card 2 of 4
For outbound sales calls: new-customer outreach, follow-ups, appointment setting, up- and cross-sell.
| Category | Checkpoints | Weight | Score |
| Opening and hook |
- Clear introduction and reason for the call
- Relevant hook to the contact's situation
- Permission to continue secured
|
15% | ___ / 6 |
| Needs and potential analysis |
- Open questions about the current situation
- Need or urgency drawn out
- Decision path or contact clarified
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Value argumentation |
- Benefits rather than bare features
- Argument tied to the contact's situation
|
20% | ___ / 4 |
| Objection handling |
- Objection acknowledged and taken seriously
- Addressed factually and with confidence
- Contact's understanding confirmed
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Closing orientation |
- Concrete close or appointment question asked
- Binding next step agreed
|
20% | ___ / 4 |
| Compliance (K.o.) |
- Marketing-call rules met (consent or a call permitted under the law)
- No false or misleading statements
|
5% | ___ / 4 |
Auto-fail: an impermissible marketing call without consent, or false statements = call scores 0 percent.
Complaint Handling
Card 3 of 4
For complaint and escalation calls: returns, dissatisfaction, intent to cancel.
| Category | Checkpoints | Weight | Score |
| De-escalation and empathy |
- Lets the contact finish, no interruptions
- Actively shows understanding of the frustration
- Keeps a calm, respectful tone
|
25% | ___ / 6 |
| Fact finding |
- Complaint captured fully and precisely
- Ownership taken, no passing the buck
|
15% | ___ / 4 |
| Resolution |
- Concrete solution or compensation offered
- Contact's expectation managed realistically
- Decided within the agent's own authority
|
25% | ___ / 6 |
| Commitment and follow-up |
- Concrete promise: what, by when, by whom
- Follow-up or callback secured
|
15% | ___ / 4 |
| Tone under pressure |
- Stayed professional and factual despite emotion
- Did not slip into justification or counterattack
|
15% | ___ / 4 |
| Documentation (K.o.) |
- Complaint categorized and documented correctly
- Legally relevant cases escalated correctly
|
5% | ___ / 4 |
Auto-fail: a legally relevant case not escalated, or a complaint not documented = call scores 0 percent.
AI Caller
Card 4 of 4
For calls handled by a voice bot or AI agent. The same card scores human and bot so the line stays comparable.
| Category | Checkpoints | Weight | Score |
| Transparency and disclosure (K.o.) |
- Discloses at the start that an AI system is speaking
- Notice is understandable and not hidden
|
10% | ___ / 4 |
| Intent recognition |
- Contact's request recognized correctly
- No misreading without a clarifying question
- Asks back when the input is unclear
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Flow and naturalness |
- Smooth turn-taking, no endless loops
- Handles interruptions cleanly
- Clear pace and language
|
20% | ___ / 6 |
| Task completion |
- Request resolved or qualified correctly
- No invented answers (no hallucination)
|
25% | ___ / 4 |
| Escalation and handover to a human |
- Edge case handed to a human in time
- Context and conversation state passed along
|
15% | ___ / 4 |
| Data protection and limits (K.o.) |
- No impermissible or unnecessary data requests
- Stayed within the approved task scope
|
10% | ___ / 4 |
Auto-fail: no disclosure that it is an AI system, or an impermissible data request = call scores 0 percent.
Worked example
An inbound call earns 4 of 6 possible points in the Resolution competence category. The category score is then 4 divided by 6, times the 30 percent weight, which is 20 percent. The six category scores added together give the call's overall score. If an auto-fail criterion is breached, the overall score is 0 percent, regardless of the other categories.
Template, not legal advice. Weights and checkpoints are a starting point and should be adapted to your industry, your processes and your compliance requirements. The notes on auto-fail criteria do not replace a legal review. In particular, align the marketing-law and data-protection points with the people responsible for them in your organization.
Built with numigtm.com · QM Scorecard Pack · Updated 19 November 2026